Water Filter Jug Comparison
An honest, data-driven comparison of two popular UK water filters — what they remove, what they cost to run, and which one belongs in your kitchen.
Our verdict
Key difference: ZeroWater uses 5-stage filtration certified to NSF 53 and 401 — it removes PFAS, fluoride, and arsenic that BRITA's basic carbon filter simply cannot touch. The trade-off is cost: ZeroWater filters run out faster and cost more to replace.
If you want genuine contaminant removal — particularly PFAS, heavy metals, or nitrate — ZeroWater is the clear winner. BRITA is the better choice for households who just want improved taste at the lowest possible running cost. In hard water areas, ZeroWater filters can last as little as two weeks, pushing annual costs well above £100, so factor that in.
BRITA is best for
Everyday taste improvement at low running cost
ZeroWater is best for
Households concerned about PFAS, heavy metals, or fluoride
Filter 1
BRITA
Marella XL + MAXTRA PRO
Filter 2
ZeroWater
12-Cup Ready-Pour
Price
£25
£40
Annual filter cost
~£52/yr
~£120/yr
Rating
4.5/5
4.3/5
Type
jug
jug
Filter life
4 weeks per cartridge
2–4 weeks depending on TDS
Certifications
TUV SUD
NSF/ANSI 53, NSF/ANSI 401
What it removes
Filtration depth
ZeroWater winsBRITA
Basic activated carbon — removes chlorine, lead, copper, mercury
ZeroWater
5-stage ion exchange — removes PFAS, fluoride, arsenic, nitrate, heavy metals
Running cost
BRITA winsBRITA
~£52/year — MAXTRA PRO filters widely available, competitively priced
ZeroWater
~£120/year — replacement filters cost more and deplete faster
Taste improvement
ZeroWater winsBRITA
Good — effective chlorine removal improves taste noticeably
ZeroWater
Excellent — removes virtually all dissolved solids for flat, pure taste
Convenience
BRITA winsBRITA
Fast pour rate, 4-week filter life, filter-change indicator
ZeroWater
Slower pour (5+ min to fill), 2–4 week filter life, TDS meter included
Certifications
ZeroWater winsBRITA
TUV SUD tested — not NSF certified
ZeroWater
NSF/ANSI 53 and 401 certified — independently verified removal claims
Everyday taste improvement at low running cost
BRITA Marella XL + MAXTRA PRO
Jug Filter · TUV SUD
Typical price
£25approx.
Affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Households concerned about PFAS, heavy metals, or fluoride
ZeroWater 12-Cup Ready-Pour
Jug Filter · NSF/ANSI 53, NSF/ANSI 401
Typical price
£40approx.
Affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
No. BRITA MAXTRA PRO filters use activated carbon, which is not fine enough to reliably remove PFAS (forever chemicals). If your postcode has flagged PFAS contamination, you need ZeroWater or an under-sink reverse osmosis system instead.
It depends on what you want to remove. ZeroWater is NSF/ANSI 401 certified to remove PFAS and NSF/ANSI 53 certified for heavy metals — claims BRITA cannot make. If you are in a high-PFAS or high-lead area, the extra cost is worth it. If you just want better-tasting water, BRITA delivers that at roughly half the annual running cost.
ZeroWater includes a TDS (total dissolved solids) meter in the box. When your filtered water reads 006 ppm on the meter — matching your unfiltered tap water — the filter is spent. In soft water areas this might last 4 weeks; in hard water areas it can be as little as 2 weeks.
BRITA is more practical in hard water areas. Because ZeroWater's 5-stage filter captures all dissolved minerals, it depletes very quickly in hard water — sometimes in under two weeks. BRITA's filter life is less affected by hardness, making it more economical if you live in London, the South East, or the Midlands.
Enter your postcode to get a detailed water quality report for your area — so you know exactly which contaminants you need to target.